| — | Kettle Moraine Lutheran | — | — | 20–4 | 1302 | 942 |
| — | Plymouth | — | — | 18–5 | 1270 | 1042 |
| — | Berlin | — | — | 15–8 | 1211 | 1083 |
| — | Waupun | — | — | 15–10 | 1198 | 1089 |
| — | Winneconne | — | — | 12–11 | 1191 | 1105 |
| — | Ripon | — | — | 5–19 | 1194 | 1381 |
| — | Campbellsport | — | — | 4–19 | 920 | 1224 |
| — | Kewaskum | — | — | 0–23 | 826 | 1371 |
Conference games only in W, L and PCT, counted from reported results. Members as listed on each team’s WIAA page. Select a column heading to sort.

Kettle Moraine Lutheran
Plymouth
Berlin
Waupun
Winneconne
Ripon
Campbellsport
Kewaskum