| — | Dominican | — | — | 17–5 | 1337 | 1018 |
| — | Saint Thomas More | — | — | 19–6 | 1386 | 1075 |
| — | Martin Luther | — | — | 15–6 | 962 | 850 |
| — | Racine Lutheran | — | — | 15–6 | 1204 | 952 |
| — | Shoreland Lutheran | — | — | 13–9 | 1275 | 1223 |
| — | The Prairie School | — | — | 8–16 | 1057 | 1235 |
| — | Catholic Central | — | — | 6–15 | 779 | 928 |
| — | Racine St. Catherine's | — | — | 3–17 | 785 | 1048 |
| — | Kenosha St. Joseph Catholic | — | — | — | 0 | 0 |
Conference games only in W, L and PCT, counted from reported results. Members as listed on each team’s WIAA page. Select a column heading to sort.

Dominican
Saint Thomas More
Martin Luther
Racine Lutheran
Shoreland Lutheran
The Prairie School
Catholic Central
Racine St. Catherine's
Kenosha St. Joseph Catholic