| — | Pius XI Catholic | — | — | 22–4 | 1644 | 1090 |
| — | Pewaukee | — | — | 21–5 | 1727 | 1087 |
| — | New Berlin Eisenhower | — | — | 18–7 | 1421 | 1166 |
| — | New Berlin West | — | — | 14–11 | 1422 | 1355 |
| — | Greendale | — | — | 9–15 | 1131 | 1254 |
| — | Wisconsin Lutheran | — | — | 8–16 | 1079 | 1205 |
| — | West Allis Central | — | — | 2–21 | 812 | 1598 |
Conference games only in W, L and PCT, counted from reported results. Members as listed on each team’s WIAA page. Select a column heading to sort.

Pius XI Catholic
Pewaukee
New Berlin Eisenhower
New Berlin West
Greendale
Wisconsin Lutheran
West Allis Central